SIL gear selector sliding dogs- any good?

[Scooterslag]

anyone have any problems with these? its only going in a 175cc engine so hardly making mega power. Paul

http://www.scooterrestorations.com/lamb ... iding-dog/

[Storkfoot]

Yes, very rough casting so the bearings would stick on the ridges. Result: very hard gear changing. I replaced it with a more expensive Italian one which was visibly better cast. Problem solved.

[Nigel. S]

I used, still am using, one in a standard 150 no probs.

[coaster]

An hour or 2 with a needle file would probably improve the change action but having fettled other Indian gearbox parts in the past to get them to fit, I would agree that it's probably better to buy better quality in the first place